Examining the home price boom and its effect on owners, lenders, regulators, realtors and the economy as a whole.
Sunday, February 05, 2006
A 'Rash Of Cancellations' In Fresno
The Fresno Bee has the latest on that bursting housing bubble. "Some home builders, trying to keep home prices down and responding to a possibly slower and highly competitive market in 2006, are planning to unveil new, more affordable designs. 'If [builders] see things taper off, they could shift the product a couple price points to midmarket or entry-market homes,' said John Karevoll."
"Lower-priced offerings would be welcome in Fresno County, where the percentage of families that could afford a median-priced home sank to record lows in 2005, the pinnacle of a five-year real estate boom in the central San Joaquin Valley."
"Rich Wathen expects more competition this year among builders, and without the escalating prices that frustrated many home buyers the last few years. 'Air is coming out of the bubble,' he said. 'There will be a lot of competition, and more as the year goes on. That will definitely have an impact on sales and prices.'"
"How much of an impact? Wathen thinks sales in the central San Joaquin Valley could fall 10% to 15%. Developers say the long waiting lists and campouts at model home sites that characterized the past few years have mostly evaporated. 'We were allowing contingency buyers over the last three years, but in October, November and December we got a rash of cancellations as homes were getting completed,' said Steve Lutton, division president of Lennar Homes."
"The greatest increase was in Fresno County, where cancellations doubled. Karevoll acknowledged the dangers of trying to assess this real estate market. '2006 will be an interesting year for the number crunchers,' he said. 'The arrows in the grass are pointing in all different directions. I've never seen the measures of uncertainty so high,' he said."
If people *think* the RE market is going to drop 10-15% it *will* drop 20-30%, especially in sh*tholes like Fresno, Modesto, Bakersfield etc..
ReplyDeleteeastofwest,
ReplyDeleteWhat is interesting about that statement is that previously, builders insisted that the land cost so much that they couldn't afford to build cheaper houses on it.
The central valley in California is one of the most bubbilicious areas in the whole country.
ReplyDeleteDavid
Bubble Meter Blog
Another dark side of the bubble: In Bakersfield, low-income workers who used to live there can no longer afford to even rent, so they are living in shacks with no utilities and peeing in open ditches.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.centralvalleybusinesstimes.com/stories/001/?ID=1234
These are workers. Not unemployed bumbs panhandling for booze money.
The people peeing itn the ditches in Kern county will be headed to LA by summer. These people are not the long time farm workers these are the roofers and drywall installers fueling the housing boom.
ReplyDeleteWait til you see what is "planned" for Bakersfield:
http://www.cityinthehills.com/
This is the most most outrageous over the top marketing blitz I've ever ever seen. The plat for the development is laser flat desert scrub NE of Bakersfield.
"Some analysts think the central San Joaquin Valley will fare better than other parts of the state because land is more plentiful and building costs — and the prices paid by home buyers — are less than at the coast."
ReplyDeleteGive me a break. There's only two reasons that the prices in this region have gone parabolic. Speculation flooding in for 'cheap' RE and funky financing have fuelled this, and both are drying up. Real income and jobs to support the current prices aren't there.
"Gauging the impact that slowing sales and appreciation rates would have on the central San Joaquin Valley is hard. An estimated 20% to 25% of new home buyers have come from the San Francisco and Los Angeles regions. What are the ramifications in the Valley if real estate market slumps in those coastal areas, Karevoll asked rhetorically."
Of the people I know who have chosen to relocate, most of them felt that they would be priced out forever or unable to own a bigger home if they didn't buy something SOMEWHERE. The plan was to build some equity and then move back to LA or SF. Meanwhile, the speculative money is already moving elsewhere, the RE related jobs are starting to evaporate while default notices and inventory are climbing. Some of these recent buyers are already underwater on homes that were supposed to give them a windfall.
I'd also add that the San Joaquin Valley is a very different place from SoCal and SF. Many of the recently relocated will find that it isn't for them, even if it is cheaper or the house is bigger.
The developer in the article who mentions building homes at a 275k price point vs. 300K as being 'more affordable' is delusional. A 25 or 50K price point reduction isn't going to save the market when affordability for the area is less than 15% and inventory is piling up rapidly.
Robert Coté said:
ReplyDeleteWait til you see what is "planned" for Bakersfield:
http://www.cityinthehills.com/
I got to this part and had to run to the john before I barfed all over my key board!
What color are your dreams? Do you gaze rolling hills of Mediterranean gold hills or stroll the shores of a swan-dotted lake under the cypresses?
Bakerfield??? I've been to Bakersfield!
Curt,
ReplyDeleteYou had the same reaction I had. This has got to be THE poster child for the coming debacle. I google mapped the location and you just wouldn't believe it.
http://www.cityinthehills.com/
Perched above the valley’s tule fog in a countryside of fresh breezes and mountain vistas, the 640 acres of City in the Hills encompass unmatched residential living, natural environments and European-inspired grandeur. Rich, inviting landscapes blend effortlessly into one another: Mediterranean gardens, an Italianate amphitheater, crystal lakes, cozy pocket parks and olive tree-lined lanes. Dappled arbor paths, paseos and greenbelts crisscross and interlink the distinctive neighborhoods with architecture inspired by Early California: Spanish Revival and Bungalow, Monterey and Cottage. The area’s microclimate cools the summer heat and lends caressing warmth to the chilliest evenings. In City in the Hills, the parts flow together to form a splendid whole—an intimate, walkable setting where green space, far-reaching views and exquisite craftmanship are a part of daily living. Here, friendships form, communities grow and the life you’ve dreamed of seems possible.
and now for the truth:
http://tinyurl.com/8rbst
I think we should all get on the mailing list and express interest in the most expensive models.
and now for the truth:
ReplyDeletehttp://tinyurl.com/8rbst
I couldn't make out the swans even under the closest zoom.