Examining the home price boom and its effect on owners, lenders, regulators, realtors and the economy as a whole.
Monday, January 30, 2006
'Builders Speculative As Demand Wanes': BW
The financial media is reporting on the housing bubble this morning. " Michael Youngblood, of Friedman, Billings, Ramsey Group Inc., has been tracking the U.S. home market for several years and forecasts steep declines in housing prices if the economy recedes over the next year. 'We expect median existing home prices to fall over 18 quarters by an average of 19.9 percent, ranging from 49.3 percent (Los Angeles) to 0.3 percent (Port St. Lucie),' he wrote in a recent report about what would happen to the most torrid markets during a sustained slowdown."
"Youngblood says he's identified pricing bubbles in 69 markets that include New York City and Nassau County, New York; Washington, D.C.; all of the urban areas in Nevada; 27 of 28 areas in California and 11 inland ones. He estimates that prices would fall by an average of 25 percent in these markets if a contraction persists for one to four years. He defines a bubble as a huge disparity in home prices relative to per-capita personal income in each market."
"If the market is slowing, as these reports suggest, buying for investment may be a bad idea unless you go bargain shopping in some of the most sluggish markets, which are generally not to be found on either coast. Selling properties you own might be wise if you need to take a profit or avoid a loss in case the bubble-prone markets deflate."
And Business Week. "It appears builders are becoming more speculative as demand is set to wane. During the second half of 2005, the supply of new single-family houses available for sale has been growing at the fastest pace since the mid-1980s. The surge in supply has corresponded with a gradual slowdown in sales and, until December, little adjustment in housing starts."
"Today's situation stands in contrast to the brief slowdown in late 2003 when a bump in long-term interest rates dampened homebuying. Inventories rose, but remained at relatively low levels. In 2003, 'it was safe to say that homebuilders had entirely avoided the temptations of speculative building,' says economist Chris Low. 'That is no longer true today.'"
"Making matters worse for homebuilders is a surge in the number of existing homes for sale, up 20.6% from a year ago. As the housing market plateaus, speculative activity will evaporate. That's when housing should slow noticeably. Home sales could post the biggest annual decline since the 6.3% fall in 1991. At that point, builders will scramble to stop projects, and the big gains in construction hiring that have helped to drive the jobless rate lower could start to reverse."
Thanks to the reader who sent in this Bellingham Herald story:
ReplyDelete'From 2000 to 2005 Whatcom County gained a new home for every 1.58 new people - 30 percent fewer people per home than the county total in 2000.
'I keep telling people I don't see explosive population growth,' said Hart Hodges, director of Western Washington University's Center for Economic and Business Research. 'I do see a heck of a lot of building.'
'Troy Muljat, a local real estate agent and developer; 'With all the permits and all the things that are being planned today, I see a massive overbuilding that's going to occur.'
'There's probably a good 35 to 40 percent that are second homes or investor purchases,' Muljat said.'
'Sandi Jones, a partner and broker, has seen investors and future retirees putting more houses into the rental market. Jones said she had just talked with a homeowner who got $1,350 a month for his four-bedroom rental house two years ago, is getting $1,200 now and expected to get $1,100 next year.
'Right now rent is a screaming deal,' she said. 'You could not possibly own a property and compete with the prices in the market.'
'People have been willing to lose money on rentals because homes were rapidly gaining in value, but they will start selling as these gains slow and homes take longer to rent out, Kent said. He said several large new housing developments coming up across the county would moderate prices even more.'
Thank God we only have one more week before the "post Super-Bowl" selling spree begins!
ReplyDeleteCurt said...
ReplyDeleteThank God we only have one more week before the "post Super-Bowl" selling spree begins
I am not familiar with the 'super bowl effect.' Can you please explain this phenomenon.
With the Super Bowl and the New season of reality television the herd just can't focus on anything else.
ReplyDeleteExactly! In fact, if the game is a blow-out (say Seattle is ahead 28 to 3 at the half), you'd better stay off the streets because a drove of buyers will be headed to the many open houses.
(If you believe this, I've got a few dozen hi-rise condos in Las Vegas I can let you have for 450% over the pre-con price.)
We expect median existing home prices to fall over 18 quarters by an average of 19.9 percent, ranging from 49.3 percent (Los Angeles) to 0.3 percent (Port St. Lucie),... He defines a bubble as a huge disparity in home prices relative to per-capita personal income in each market.
ReplyDeleteThe timing is spot on if we start Q4 '05 but there's a problem with his denominator. LA has a low per capita income because of demographics in addition to high housing prices. Likewise the total cost of ownership is not part of his calculation.
"'We expect median existing home prices to fall over 18 quarters by an average of 19.9 percent, ranging from 49.3 percent (Los Angeles) to 0.3 percent (Port St. Lucie),'"
ReplyDelete***********
Finally some numbers to describe the downturn.
So for those in LA, "shorthand" here would be: "4.5 year decline of 50%."
Youngblood is saying what I've been saying here for months:
ReplyDeleteQ2 '06 Silent Spring 80%
Q2 '07 Holding You Breath 73%
Q2 '08 Treading Water 66%
Q2 '09 Last Gasp 59%
Q2 '10 End of The Ride 52%
After a holiday slowdown, the Super Bowl each year marks the start of housing's prime season.
ReplyDeleteI remember when there couldn't be a bubble because the regional builders had gotten lean and mean during the last bust, consolidated, learned the lesson of overbuilding and were diversified by region! HA!
ReplyDelete