Examining the home price boom and its effect on owners, lenders, regulators, realtors and the economy as a whole.
Tuesday, January 31, 2006
2006 Forecast 'Might Now Be Too Optimistic'
The Greeley Tribune looks at the housing market in that area of Colorado. "Fewer homes sold in Windsor in 2005 than the year before, but average prices jumped 15 percent. The jump in housing costs worries Gary Haddock, a Windsor Town Board member and affordable-housing advocate. 'I'd love to see how many incomes increased by that much,' he said of the recent price spike. 'It just highlights the difference between our incomes and the cost of housing.'"
"To buy a $300,000 home requires an annual income of at least $85,000 with $10,000 for a down payment, according to LoanWeb.com Haddock said 48 percent of Windsor households earn less than $50,000, and the town's average household income is $60,000. Most homes sold in Windsor last year fell in the $150,000-$300,000 (285 homes) and $300,000-$500,000 price ranges (212)."
And one economist was in northern Colorado to perk up the troops. "The real estate market in Northern Colorado will mirror the national market, slowing down in 2006, but the industry here will still expand slightly as the state continues to see slight population influx, said David Lereah. 'The real estate boom is over. But as you've seen in Colorado, it's been a soft landing, not a crash,' said Lereah."
"'It's not a real estate bubble, it's a balloon, and in Colorado, you've seen the air has come out with overbuilding on the market and with job losses.'"
"Three risks facing the Northern Colorado market are overbuilding, drastic interest-rate increases and a simultaneous mass exodus of 'flippers,' or small-time investors putting properties on the market that they bought on speculation. The region also should be wary of a high percentage of homes purchased by buyers who didn't fully understand exactly how much variable-interest loans would increase after two or three years."
"Though Mike Sutton in Fort Collins, agreed the real estate boom won't completely bust, he said home prices have leveled off recently. 'We do have a lot of supply (of available properties for sale on the market) right now,' Sutton said. 'We're experiencing what a lot of other markets may see in the near future.'"
"The main message Sutton took away from the regional forecast? 'It's time to be careful, to be thoughtful and creative,' Sutton said."
"Across the country, home sales declined 5.7 percent from November to a seasonally adjusted annual pace of 6.6 million, the slowest since March 2004, according to the NAR. 'I hadn't expected that for two or three months,' said David Lereah, chief economist for NAR, who conceded that his forecast for 2006 might now be too optimistic."
This from the official website of NYC as Bloomberg announced the FY 2006 budget:
ReplyDelete"New York’s real estate market is expected to slow, however, with a 10% decline in home prices, a 14% decline in home sales over the next few years and a significant decline in real estate transaction taxes that have buoyed the City’s tax revenue in the last few fiscal years."
He was very explicit about this when questioned today by reporters, he mentioned slowing sales and the fact that price reductions logically follow as people need to sell homes.
Thanks to the readers who sent in these articles.
ReplyDeleteWhat a clown David Lereah is. The fact that he was *allowed* by the media to forecast the health of the housing industry is no different from those rinky-dink dot-com analysts putting "Strong Buy" ratings on equities that were underwritten by their own banks.
ReplyDeleteWe expect industry-whores like Lereah to paint optimistic pictures, but the media has no excuse for using him as a source as much as they did. This guy is going to have zero credibility moving forward. Neither should the financial media.
sohonyc,
ReplyDeleteMany don't realize DL predicted that in 2004, prices would stabilize, but they exploded. He said the same thing about 2005, and then 'revised' it mid-summer to fit the facts. IMO, he's wrong about 2006, too.
Getting harder for David L. to paint this turd!
ReplyDeleteBloomberg is probably scared badly about this. As he knows, a 10% decline will wipe out all the remaining equity that everyone has in their houses as a result of the prices appreciating since 2000. The rest of the appreciation since Jan. 2000 has already been eaten up by 100% mortgages and Refi's. So, even as home prices have increased by large amounts in the last 5 years, the average homeowner will be in worse shape now after just a 10% decline then in Jan. 2000! If anyone is interested in the numbers I can work it through for you.
ReplyDeleteAnybody else, like me, think Mayor Mike is using "10%" in order not to scare anybody, or piss off the housing lobby or whatever?
ReplyDeleteI think he actually thinks it could be somewhat worse.
He and his staff picked 10% because it's a nice round number for a decline over the next few years. They could be thinking that while it may cause "some" amount of panic, whatever that might mean, he certainly can't be blamed with that figure (reality or not, whatever happens) for the impending housing price decline.
it is unfortunate that so many first time and other home buyers have had to buy with 100 % financing no money down I/O ARM's especially in 2005. The Re agents,mortgage bankers, all in the business of financing these exotic loans to desperate-to-get-into-homes buyers have no interest in the grave risks of these loans. As is true of all business/contractual transactions it is buyer beware and it will be a hard lesson with many unfortunate victims down the road.
ReplyDeleteI do think that the housing bubble will slowly lose air and prices will show a slight decline 1n 2006, maybe faster in some overheated markets. I do not wish ill for current homeowners but there are too many negative factors and portents. The main factors are affordability, income/house price ratio's, rent vvs home ownership cost ratios,degree of speculation,ect.
The 5-6 homes for sale in my neighborhood have not moved since sept-oct 2005.