Wednesday, February 01, 2006

Pending Home Sales, Borrowing Down

The pending sales data is suggesting the housing boom is over. "Pending sales of U.S. homes dropped in December to the lowest point in almost two years, extending a months-long slide as the housing market shows signs of sustained cooling, a trade group said on Wednesday. The National Association of Realtors said its Pending Home Sales Index, based on contracts signed in December, stood at 116.4, down 3.0 percent from November and 5.5 percent below a year ago. December's level marked the lowest point for the index since February 2004, when it hit 111.6, the Realtors said. It also may indicate a decline in home sales for January and February. Long-term mortgage rates have once again started to climb, and earlier on Wednesday the Mortgage Bankers Association said mortgage applications fell for the first time in four weeks." "The PHSI in the South rose 2.3 percent in December to 135.9 and was 4.1 percent above December 2004. In the Northeast, the index increased 1.5 percent to 90.7 but was 11.1 percent below December 2004. The index in the West fell 8.1 percent to 117.1 in December and was 11.8 percent lower than a year ago. The index in the Midwest dropped 9.3 percent to a level of 105.8 and was 11.0 below December 2004." "David Lereah, NAR’s chief economist, said, 'We’re going through a period of adjustment. As home sellers recognize a return to more normal rates of price growth, some that have been holding out for higher prices will be more willing to negotiate terms that are acceptable to buyers but still provide them a solid return on their investment.'" "The popularity of home-equity loans and refinances is declining. Freddie Mac reports that as interest-rates rise, prime borrowers (those with the best credit) are taking out fewer cash-out refinances. For the first time since mid-1999, the total volume of revolving home-equity lines of credit also dropped this past fall." And from the Wall Street Journal. "Hoping to ride a new wave of profits as the mortgage boom winds down, lenders have changed course and are targeting borrowers with adjustable-rate mortgages and encouraging them to refinance into fixed-rate loans. The latest refinancing push comes as declining loan volume and increased competition is putting pressure on lenders' bottom lines." "They are trying 'to drum up that last little bit of business' as loan volume declines, says Amy Crews Cutts, deputy chief economist at the mortgage finance company Freddie Mac. 'They have too much time on their hands and too many employees sitting around.'"

22 comments:

  1. The pending sales measure is relatively new. The NAR came up with it because so many other data is backward looking, so this is a better indicator of what is happening now.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Take a look at the housing index, it's off 50% for the day!


    http://finance.yahoo.com/q?d=t&s=^HGX

    http://bigcharts.marketwatch.com/quickchart/quickchart.asp?symb=hgx&sid=0&o_symb=hgx&freq=1&time=8&x=0&y=0

    ReplyDelete
  3. "We’re going through a period of adjustment."

    Yep. The adjustment means there will be less home sales and price declines will be occuring in the bubble market.


    "As home sellers recognize a return to more normal rates of price growth"

    Wrong. Prices will not grow in the bubble markets, they will be shrinking. Price will be declining in the bubble markets and at best stagnating in the non bubble markets.

    David 'Soft Landing' Lereah is still spinning the market conditions. [Sometimes I wish there was a Lereah watch Blog]

    David
    Bubble Meter Blog

    ReplyDelete
  4. (lenders have changed course and are targeting borrowers with adjustable-rate mortgages and encouraging them to refinance into fixed-rate loans.)

    last year they were telling you how great those loans were, now they'll tell you how bad they are!

    ReplyDelete
  5. dwr,
    Funny! I have a feeling that Lereah will be made a major scrapegoat in a few short months.
    Really, it's been pointed out here several times that he is the mouthpiece for a decidedly one-sided organization that promotes the interests of real estate brokers/agents exclusively...I hate it when he's quoted as some sort of sage about the housing market. Sorta like asking Jeffrey Skilling about Enron accounting.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I thought it interesting that Freddie Mac expects the volume of cash-out refis from prime mortgages is expected to drop to $114.5 billion this year from a record $204 billion in 2005.

    Likewise, for the first time since mid-1999, the total volume of revolving home-equity lines of credit dropped this past fall.

    ----------

    If you subtract the GDP contributions made by (1) rampant residential construction and (2) mortgage financed consumer spending, things could get rough quick.

    ReplyDelete
  7. "They are trying 'to drum up that last little bit of business' as loan volume declines, says Amy Crews Cutts, deputy chief economist at the mortgage finance company Freddie Mac. 'They have too much time on their hands and too many employees sitting around.'"

    Sounds like there are too many overpaid, lazy butts just warming the chairs these days in the RE industry.

    Time to let the pink slips fly.

    ReplyDelete
  8. privatebanker says...
    "Of course we saw this coming. But what happens when most of the borrowers do not qualify for traditional 15 & 30 yr. fixed mortgages? They may not have the cash flow to support a higher payment or their house may not appraise high enough to qualify for a lender's loan to value guidelines. I guess that's where the shady lenders/appraisers come in, only to position the borrower at more of a disadvantage."

    I already heard that shady guy from Lennox Financial on the radio this morning hyping refi from ARM into fixed..."doesn't cost a nickel" and "we've fiananced some guys 5 times!"....
    karma, karma, karma...where are you?

    ReplyDelete
  9. David: Good post! "As home sellers recognize a return to more normal rates of price growth"

    I love how everyone in the business continues to argue that prices will still increase-only at a slower pace. I can't wait for undeniable price declines to occur so the lying will finally cease!

    Could you post your link again. The one that you posted is a dead link.
    -thanks

    ReplyDelete
  10. That number can't be right. Of the 21 comapnies that make up PHLX the worst are off by only around 2% today. EIther Yahoo is messed up or some artificial change to the index took place.

    That's why I included Bigcharts too. Something must be wrong with the reporting system...?

    ReplyDelete
  11. Lereah is so full of shit. he'll make things seem great all the way to rock bottom!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I would like to start a website called www.painttheturd.com that would just follow David Lereah and the things he says. As I recall, not 3 months or so ago he was still saying, "No bubble here. Nothing to see here."

    He is doing what every flipper has been doing:

    Buy It, Paint It, Sell It (Hopefully for more)

    We call that painting the turd.

    Peace

    ReplyDelete
  13. Construction Spending Sets Record in 2005

    they'll build right through the bubble bursting and then some!

    ReplyDelete
  14. I'd say it looks like a split but I don't know if they do that with indices.

    ReplyDelete
  15. OT, but I have noticed that of the hundreds of spam emails I am getting, the percentage hawking refis has gone way down since the beginning of the year.

    In 2005 a clear majority were refi related, now <10% are. Appears that the ROI of these mailings has gone down.

    Anyone also seeing this?

    ReplyDelete
  16. Regarding ^HGX. Ever hear of a stock split?

    ReplyDelete
  17. The NAR economist should tell this to the sellers in MA. Somehow, the greedy sellers here, having mostly bought their property dirt cheap prior to 2000, havn't got the message. The asking prices have not moved much downward since Oct 2005. What are they wating for? Buyer fatigue?

    Many can't lower their asking prices because they've already cashed out all of their equity and spent it. Appreciation can't bail them out any more and they have no money to bring to closing.

    Hence the sticky sales prices--- for now.

    ReplyDelete
  18. lunarpark said...

    OT - Anyone else in the Bay Area catch the Vallco article in the Mercury News today? I guess developers won approval to build condos at Vallco as part of the refurbishment project. Someone in the article stated that Cupertino is turning into "Condotino" (LOL) with at least 1,000 pending condo projects. Sort of reminds me of all those office buildings they built in Sunnyvale right before the dotcom fall. Most of them are still empty.


    The Vallco Village Mall was built in the 60s-70s. It was pretty dated until Chinese investors bought it a few years back. They refurbished it and now it's like a little Chinatown. Most of the store signs are written only in Chinese.

    Chinese tradionally love real estate so I'm guessing the Chinese will snap up most all of the Vallco condos. There is a lot of yuan sloshing around looking for a home.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I am glad that Vallco won approval to build condos. It is one beautiful victory against California NIMBYism.

    ReplyDelete
  20. lunarbaby said:

    "Someone in the article stated that Cupertino is turning into 'Condotino' (LOL) with at least 1,000 pending condo projects. Sort of reminds me of all those office buildings they built in Sunnyvale right before the dotcom fall. Most of them are still empty."

    ********

    "Condotino" condos for everyone!

    And you're not kidding about quiet dotcom era buildings in Santa Clara/Sunnyvale.

    I've actually seen, in the last few months, a few workers in a few buildings that were empty for about five years. And I've seen traffic pick a little recently in the area, but not a lot.

    Perhaps its the usual seasonal thing and I'm extrapolating wrongly - as not many around here go anywhere but to work, and certainly not on extended vacations, during January.

    ReplyDelete
  21. There is a lot of growth in tech these days, it's just not for SV-- All the big tech hiring is being offshored to India. Five years after the dot.bomb, the SV job market is still flat to declining.

    I read an article last year and the Stanford dean of engineering was quoted, 'why would anyone want to go through the rigors of our engineering program then deal with poor career prospects when those in the business school graduate making more money, doing deals on the golf course.'

    As an engineer myself, I tend to agree when I see lots of educated, talented tech employees kicked to the curb and their jobs shipped to India/China. Many of them ended up in the RE industry to make ends meet, but they could have done that with merely a HS diploma.

    ReplyDelete
  22. What people need to realize is that there is an inverted relationship between mortgage rates and home sales / prices. Check out this chart regarding this and it's very clear. http://www.californiarealestatecenter.com/blog/

    As pending home sales drop, home values will soon follow.

    ReplyDelete