Thursday, January 26, 2006

Housing Boom Doesn't Create Growth': Econ.

The New York Post had this to report. "It's not the end of the world, just the first signs that the housing bubble is beginning to deflate. That's the verdict economists delivered yesterday on the data that show an unexpectedly steep slump in the sales of existing homes in December." "The NAR reported sales of previously owned homes slid 5.7 percent in December over November levels, with about 6.6 million properties changing hands compared to 7 million in November 2005. The market had been braced for a decline, but not of this magnitude. More striking still, it's the third-straight month that the volume of real estate transactions has fallen since peaking at 7.35 million units last June." "For New Yorkers and others in the Northeast, the picture is slightly brighter. In contrast to steep declines in the South and West, sales of existing homes in the Northeast were flat in December." "Still, this is no time for complacency, economists agree. In a note fired off to clients, Ian Shepherdson, chief U.S. economist for High Frequency Economics, warned that this is just the start. 'We expect price increases to slow much further, dragging down expectations for future price gains and therefore raising real mortgage rates,' Stepherdson cautioned." "'This will be the trigger for a serious collapse in home sales later this week. The housing market is a bubble, and it will burst,' he said." And Newsday had this, "Real wages across Long Island fell during the past three years, leaving residents with declining incomes once they accounted for rising prices for everything from gasoline to health care to food." "In Nassau County, real average weekly wages fell 3.2 percent between the first quarter of 2002 and the first quarter of 2005, according to data collected from the regional Bureau of Labor Statistics and analyzed by Newsday. In Suffolk, the drop was 4.2 percent over the same period, while Queens saw a 3.7 percent decline." "The declines were widespread, in industries ranging from construction and manufacturing to leisure and hospitality and transportation. In Suffolk County, every industry saw wage declines except one. professional and business services, the data showed." "At a time when the region's economy has continuous job growth, rising housing prices and good consumer spending, the wage data is particularly disconcerting, area economists said. 'This really underscores that just because there's a booming housing market, it doesn't translate into strong economic growth,' said James Parrott, chief economist for the Fiscal Policy Institute in Manhattan. 'It suggests that consumption spending has a built-in speed limit to it. You just can't expect to grow very fast.'" "But even without real wage gains, consumers have kept spending. How? 'The answer is debt,' said Martin Cantor, the chief economist for Sustainable Long Island. 'The pump is being primed by debt, but not by real growth.'"

8 comments:

  1. I couldn't get into Blogger for a couple of hours, so all comments should be updated by now.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good article! Finally the truth be told regarding wages, and house prices. More stories like this will be coming out in the coming months.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yeah, Blogger was kinda screwed earlier...

    I can't believe the mass media campaign Centex is pushing in my local market... TV, radio, all trumpeting the 'sale of the century'. And Ohio isn't even a bubble market, far from it. But like most other areas, a large fraction of job growth around here has been due to the building industry. If Centex is advertising $70k off a house (saw it on TV tonight), it doesn't look good for the building trade.

    ReplyDelete
  4. "But even without real wage gains, consumers have kept spending. How? 'The answer is debt,' said Martin Cantor, the chief economist for Sustainable Long Island. 'The pump is being primed by debt, but not by real growth.'"

    "Real Growth?" How old school- Didn't he get the memo about the new paradigm?

    We can borrow against our ever-rising home equity and spend like drunken sailors forever and ever. No work, free money. All you have to do to get in the game is start buying RE!

    ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  5. john in va

    Looking at Centex's site, I'm guessing that the $70k is taken off of a higher-priced house (for our area) of about $400k... not even a 20% knock-down. And yes, last year that would have gotten a reaction.

    I recall back around 1984-ish, seeing people in Cincinnati camped out downtown, in front of a mortgage place that was offering 8.99% loans. Looks like those days will be coming back.

    ReplyDelete
  6. "Aha -- so this is Fannie Mae's survival gimmick, thanks to your elected representatives:"

    But my favorite part is this quote: "Accounting issues at Fannie... have led Congress to consider measures to stiffen oversight of the companies by creating a new regulator.

    So they create a monster that inevitably loses control and instead of banishing the monster they spend more money hiring a babysitter for the monster. Maybe that's why government is known as The Leviathan.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Jimmy the Saint: Do you know where we could see pictures of 6 houses for sale in a row? I don't know why news is really poor with pictures.

    ReplyDelete
  8. That's hilarious about McCain's reduced price mansion. There was an article not too long ago about Manny Ramirez reducing the price of his mansion that wasn't moving.

    Anyone want to put together a blog of wildly overpriced properties? There wouldn't be a shortage of material.

    ReplyDelete