Examining the home price boom and its effect on owners, lenders, regulators, realtors and the economy as a whole.
Wednesday, January 25, 2006
'False Assertions Of Bubble Delay Sales': MAR
The Massachusetts realtors have the December numbers out. "Sales of detached single-family homes fell in December for a third consecutive month compared to year ago levels, the first time since April-June 2003 that detached home sales have declined for three straight months."
The talking points memo somehow forgot to mention what the full PDF file states. The year-over-year decline in detached SFH sales was 8.8%, with 3,574 sold.
"The more moderate sales pace reflects softening buyer demand due to higher mortgage rates and a weak job market, as well as increased inventory levels, which have led to a more balanced market in which buyers don’t feel the same sense of urgency to make a quick offer as they did when supply levels were tighter. False assertions of a price bubble in the local market also have prompted some buyers to delay their home buying decisions"
"The sales decline of 3.7 percent that took place between November and December is not unusual and generally reflects seasonal changes. On a month-to-month basis, home sales have now declined for four consecutive months, dating back to August 2005."
"The supply of detached single-family homes on the market rose for a tenth consecutive month in December, increasing 31.8 percent over the past year from 22,593 homes for sale in December 2004 to 29,771 this December. Inventory, as stated in months of supply also has risen steadily from 5.8 months last December to 8.3 months of supply in December 2005. Active listings are up from November as well, when there was 28,152 listings and 7.6 months of supply."
"In Massachusetts, the market is at equilibrium for buyers and sellers when 7.5-8.5 months of housing supply exists, thus despite concerns about an inventory glut, there’s a healthy balance between supply and demand at the present time."
"First-time buyers and empty-nesters looking to downsize and purchase second homes continue to boost condo sales to record levels. The 1,627 units sold in December set a new state record for the month, eclipsing the prior record of 1,580 condos sold in December 2004. The number of condos for sale has increased 43.2 percent in the past year, from 10,180 units last December to 14,581 in December 2005. Inventory, as stated in months of supply, also has risen in the past year, climbing to 9 months of supply this past December from 6.4 months of supply in December 2004."
"Compared to a month earlier, condo listings have increased 12 percent from November when there were 13,024 condo units on the market and 8 months of supply."
"The statewide median selling price for detached single-family homes rose modestly by 2.6 percent in the past 12 months to $354,000. The predictions of steep price declines in home values that were made this fall are largely unfounded. While the current median price is 5.6 percent below the record high monthly median of $375,000 set in July and August 2005 (due to monthto-month price declines in September and October), prices rose 1.7 percent in November and have stabilized in December."
"Condo prices also have begun to moderate, with the statewide median selling price rising 3.8 percent in November from year-ago levels. The median price of $275,000 is down 4.5 percent from the record high median selling price of $287,900 set in July 2005."
Note: the monthly data at the MAR site are PDF files. Also, blogger has scheduled some downtime today, about 15 minutes they say, at 4:PM PST.
ReplyDeleteThis one press release contains the most buzzwords I think I have ever seen in one document.
ReplyDelete"False assertions of a price bubble in the local market..."
ReplyDeleteThat's a false assertion in itself.
Jeez.
I saw this posted somewhere else (maybe at patrick.net) and it was quoted from something here.
ReplyDeleteI guess it bears repeating, considering who might be making "false assertions" about the existence of a housing bubble:
"Mission & Vision
The core purpose of the NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® is to help its members become more profitable and successful."
You know, I really think I could use a national association to make me "more profitable and more successful."
ReplyDeleteLying den of thieves.
Before now, I wasn't really ready to accept the notion (as others here were) that sometime in 2008 or 2010 there might be hearings on Capitol Hill about the duplicitous behavior we've come to see regularly in real estate.
ReplyDeleteHowever, today, I've had change in viewpoint. The lawyers are gonna love this crap and whatever else the NAR, the MAR, the CAR and others are peddling.
Whew! Now that they've reassured the masses, I can just see all those bubble-delayed purchasers rushing out to buy homes.
ReplyDeleteThey can spin all they want, but the freakish increase in MA inventories over the past year are telling. I've posted the historical numbers over at:
http://masshousemarket.blogspot.com/
mad_tiger said...
ReplyDelete"In Massachusetts, the market is at equilibrium for buyers and sellers when 7.5-8.5 months of housing supply exists"
What is the basis for this? I've seen numbers as low as 4 months' inventory claimed as "equilibrium" between buyers and sellers.
3:30 PM
Oh, this one's easy...the number of months of supply that equates to a 'balanced' market is equal to the current months of supply plus a number no less than .5.
E.g., expect this CAR release in July:
"In the Modesto housing market in June, there were 3 sales and 3000 active listings, equating to 1000 months of supply. A housing market is considered balanced when there are 1001 months of supply."
don't worry, these people will all suffer the same embarassing fate as the wall street magicians did.
ReplyDeleteWhen sales volume and prices go up, it is obviously because of "stong fundamentals".
ReplyDeleteWhen sales volume and prices go down, it is obviously because of "false assertions".
The Workplace: U.S. economy strong? Not for wages and jobs
ReplyDeleteChina: A Bull in the Energy Shop
Vegas Condos Go Cold
Developers are suddenly scaling back their bets on the town's once sizzling luxury real estate market
Why Wall Street had a record year and you didn't
ReplyDeleteThe S&P had a measly return of 4.9 percent. Securities firms gave out a record $21.5 billion in year-end bonuses. That's fair.
MAR: I guess affordability is never a question. There is no way it could affect a buyer's motivation to buy. It's all due to UFO-like conspiracy theories!!
ReplyDeleteIn Massachusetts, the market is at equilibrium for buyers and sellers when 7.5-8.5 months of housing supply exists
ReplyDeleteSeems so scientific- Just take the current months of supply (e.g., 8.0), then add & subtract 0.5 and *presto*, you have the "equilibrium" range-
I didn't know that economics could be so easy!
-PT Barnum